The third album, Back Burner (2011), introduced heavier clean vocals and guitar-driven compositions. Written after songwriter Andrew Tkaczyk's departure, it built on their melodic roots while embracing a more aggressive tone.
Wasted Youth (2012), their only release under Artery Recordings, showcased dynamic songwriting, technical drumming, and a post-hardcore edge. It featured bassist Brandon Stastny and drummer Dylan Shippey in new roles.
Vocalist Dylan Richter returned in 2013 as the band signed back with Rise Records. Their fifth full-length, Heavy Hearts (2014), peaked at #162 on Billboard 200 and #3 on Heatseekers, blending emotional lyricism with crushing breakdowns.